# Chapter 23: The Butterfly That Wouldn’t Stay Hidden
Hello everyone, it’s me again! How are you all doing? Today I will continue to walk with you and review Chapter 23 of “Forget You Saw Her free digital audiobook.” This is the chapter where hope begins to curdle into grief, where a tiny butterfly earring becomes both a clue and a legal liability, and where Sabina learns that finding evidence is not the same thing as finding justice.
Sabina cannot stop thinking about the earring. She does not touch it again, afraid she has already ruined everything by taking it in the first place. But she also knows that if she had not snatched it from beneath the table, she never would have known what it was. Paloma never would have seen it in her car. And Paloma never would have told her the truth: that she had given those earrings to Andrea on the morning she disappeared. It was the best of Sabina’s bad choices. At least, that is what she tells herself.
Then Detective Monte Barker arrives. He is not what Sabina expected. She had braced herself for a grizzled small-town detective with a gray mustache, arthritic hands, and a permanent scowl. Instead, Barker is younger, mid-thirties, with a clean-shaven baby face, bright blue eyes, white-blond hair, and a trendy haircut. He seems intelligent and kind. Sweet, even. He uses gloves to gently retrieve the butterfly earring from the seat of Sabina’s car and bag it after verifying Paloma’s tiny initials on the underside of the right wing.
Sabina expects to be berated. She expects him to scold her for stealing the earring, for entering the Beaumont home, for inserting herself into the investigation without permission. He does none of that. He greets Paloma and Nadia by name, clearly having spoken with them more than once. When Sabina shakes his hand and introduces herself, he nods slowly and squeezes her hand, as if he understands exactly why she is here.
At the police station, Barker directs Sabina, Paloma, and Nadia into separate interview rooms. Sabina is questioned first. She walks him through everything Bunny Beaumont told her and describes what she saw inside the house—including Andrea’s pathetic excuse for a bedroom and the fact that all of her belongings had already been packed into storage. She tells him about finding the earring at the last second before Dennis Beaumont insisted she leave. She relays Nadia’s stories about Isabel Palphreyman. She explains how Paloma saw the earring in her car after school. Barker does not say much. He asks a few questions, nods for her to continue, and mostly lets her talk.
When Sabina finally runs out of words, she reaches for the question burning inside her. “This is enough to search their house, right?” she demands. “He did something to her. I know he did.” The fluorescent lights buzz too loudly. The ringing phones and creaking plastic chairs feel absurdly ordinary for the conversation happening in this cramped room.
Detective Barker lets out a slow, careful breath. His eyes flick to the camera in the corner, its red light blinking. He tells her he understands her frustration, but it is not that simple. He cannot share details about the direction of the investigation. Right now, he is merely asking questions. No answers in return. He explains that the earring might be significant, but from a defense lawyer’s perspective, it would be the first piece of evidence on the chopping block. It is a chain-of-custody nightmare. Who is to say where or how Sabina got it? Who is to say she did not plant it at the Beaumonts’ house?
Sabina feels physically ill. “I didn’t—I wouldn’t—” But Barker holds up a hand. He is not accusing her. He is telling her why he cannot go kicking down doors right this second. If he walked into a judge’s office today and asked for an arrest warrant, they would laugh him out of the room. A defense lawyer with half a brain would have the Beaumonts out within the hour.
Sabina argues that the earring proves Dennis was lying. It proves Andrea came home after school that afternoon. There are three people willing to testify that Paloma gave Andrea those earrings for her birthday, the morning she disappeared. But Barker interrupts, his voice edged now. He is looking at all possibilities. He will consider the new information. But all he can tell her is that they will use the statements and any potential evidence in whatever ways the legal system will allow.
Sabina folds her arms tightly against her stomach and closes her eyes. She is so tired, so overwhelmed by grief and frustration that she wants to lay her head on the scarred tabletop and fall asleep. Then Barker says gently, “Ms. Turpin.” He waits until she meets his gaze. “If something violent happened to your daughter, I want the person responsible for it behind bars. Believe me, I do. And right now, that promise is the best thing I can offer you.”
For a moment, neither of them speaks. Sabina stares back at him, trying to memorize the sincerity in those baby-blue eyes. Then she walks out of the police station to wait in her car. She fixes her eyes on the bright orange clouds above the horizon as the sun sinks lower and lower. The quilt-wrapped feeling is conspicuously absent, replaced by a hollowness in her chest.
She tries to tell herself that it has been less than twenty-four hours since she arrived. In that tiny amount of time, she has accomplished a lot. She made contact with the Beaumonts. She found Paloma and Nadia. She discovered a clue that confirmed her suspicions about Bunny and Dennis Beaumont. They were liars at best. And at worst? Sabina shuts her eyes and watches the after-image of the blazing clouds fizzle into spots of yellow and green, then darkness.
With every passing minute, she becomes more sure that the worst has happened to her baby. Andrea is not missing. She is dead. It is an intuition that has been growing since she first heard Bunny’s voice on the phone. A horrible knowing that crowds out the last desperate hope that Andrea might still be out there, waiting to be found by someone who would love her the way she always deserved to be loved.
When Nadia and Paloma emerge from the police station an hour later, Sabina sees the same realization in their stricken expressions. They look hollowed out. Paloma especially. Her mascara has dripped down her face along with her tears, smeared into black streaks across her cheeks. In her red-rimmed eyes, Sabina sees the understanding that Andrea probably will not be reading any of the kind messages on the Facebook page she and Nadia created, urging Andrea to come home.
Sabina fully believes Detective Barker when he says a judge would probably laugh him out of the office if he asked for an arrest warrant right now. But at this point, she would bet almost anything that Dennis Beaumont was the one who made Andrea disappear, no matter what a judge thinks.
Nadia promises they will talk again soon. They exchange phone numbers. She wraps Sabina in a hug, but there is no urgency in her voice anymore. Paloma turns away without saying goodbye and gets into the passenger seat of Nadia’s Toyota. Sabina gives them a feeble wave, then returns to her car and pulls out her phone. She has a missed call and a couple of texts from Joel, asking her to call him.
She knows that if she returns his call right now, she will either become a crying mess for the dozenth time in a few hours, or she will snap at him. Not because he deserves it, but because the stew of anger, horror, and sadness in her stomach is churning so hard. She has used up every bit of her social niceties trying not to explode on the strangers she spent the day with.
She types: *I love you. Tsunami. Talk in the morning?* Tsunami is the code word they have used since the first year they were married. It means one of them is too overwhelmed to connect without melting down. A disaster that needs time for the waves to recede.
The text bubbles appear almost immediately. Then: *I love you too. Hang on.* Along with a photo of a life preserver. Sabina clings to that message like the lifeline it is, all the way back to the Airbnb.
---
## Reader’s Impressions & Star Rating
This chapter is a slow-burning emotional gut punch. There is no big chase, no dramatic confession, and yet it hurts deeply because it captures the cruel gap between what we know in our bones and what can be proven in a courtroom. Detective Barker is a wonderful surprise—kind, careful, and realistic. He does not become a villain or a savior. He becomes a human being trapped inside a system that demands more than a mother’s intuition. The butterfly earring is such a small object, but it carries the weight of Andrea’s whole vanished life. Sabina’s “Tsunami” text with Joel is a tiny, beautiful light in the middle of all this darkness.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rating: 4.8 / 5 Stars
## Next Chapter Prediction
The next chapter will likely bring the first ripple from the earring’s discovery. Detective Barker may call with an update after testing it for prints or DNA, or Sabina may decide she cannot wait for the legal system to move. I suspect the mystery of Isabel Palphreyman will deepen, and Bunny or Dennis Beaumont will make a dangerous move to control the narrative. Joel may arrive to stand beside Sabina, giving her the emotional anchor she desperately needs. But the biggest prediction? Chapter 24 will reveal a new piece of Andrea’s final hours—something that turns Sabina’s horrible knowing into a plan for confrontation.
To listen free the next reviews chatpers, please access website novelsaudio.com and search keyword: Forget You Saw Her free digital audiobook or click the link in the description of this video or if you want to listen or read full the Forget You Saw Her free digital audiobook please access website Novelsaudio.com