# CHAPTER 4: The Start of Time, an Oreo Milkshake, and the Question Nobody Had Asked
Hello everyone, it's me again! How are you all doing? I hope you're cozy, because today I'm walking with you through CHAPTER 4 of *The Love Proof* — and I have to tell you honestly, this is the chapter where the story stops being about two clever students in a library and quietly becomes something much bigger. Today we get first dates disguised as study sessions, a question about the beginning of the universe, a kiss under 13.8 billion years of starlight, and a professor who jots down an idea that might just break physics wide open. So settle in. Let's go.
It begins hours after Jake and Sophie first met — he texted her about studying, and now here they are, descending into Bass, Yale's underground library, where leather chairs, marble tables, and bookcases line up with the precision of a royal garden. They claim a study room meant for a small group, and both of them are drowning in proximity. Sophie unpacks her backpack and starts imagining how their elbows might graze if she forgot her own body. Jake, inches away, notices something new: Sophie doesn't smell like anything. No lip gloss, no bronzer, no perfume thick enough to fog a classroom — just plain clean. To a boy raised around Trinity girls who started armoring themselves in middle school, her naturalness is startling. It has, as the book puts it, the quality of being undressed.
He clears his throat and opens his $1,199 laptop, tabs ready: *Wall Street Journal*, *New York Times*, *Barron's*, and a Google doc called simply "Future," where he writes down where he believes the world is going. Sophie uncaps a Bic pen and leaks her mind onto Professor Malchik's problem set in neat blue print — sigmas and integrals, elegant little vines.
Then something beautiful happens. They relax into the silence. For an hour, neither of them speaks. When Sophie resurfaces at 7:32 p.m., first problem solved, she looks up and finds Jake locked inside his own focus cocoon — and the strange feeling that she's staring at herself. There's passion in his concentration. Being this close to him while he's unselfconscious feels intimate. *What is happening between us?* she wonders. The ease, so soon after meeting. She sinks back into her work. At 8:16 he waves a hand between them, catches her, and she covers her face, embarrassed. "It was cute," he says. "We disappear." And she smiles, because he understands.
He offers to fetch her something from Bass Café. "Milkshake." Oreo. He laughs — her eagerness reminds him of being very small, falling asleep in restaurants, the illicit allure of sugar — and goes upstairs, where he waits behind four ponytailed girls chattering about Franzia, a Mike Posner concert, being gluten-free, and a stoplight party where green means go and red means taken. Every topic with the half-life of a spark that never catches. He glances back toward the library, thinking about *her*.
Then he pays five fifty for her milkshake and realizes, with a small jolt: *they're on a date.* He'd always assumed dating meant bright plumage, chest-puffing, nervous energy, self-doubt. But every moment with Sophie is calm. A date where two people simply do what they would have done alone. He carries back her sixteen ounces of whipped cream and Oreo crumbs and his free cup of tap water, and finds her deep in thought.
"What've you been working on?" he asks.
"The start of time."
She's solving the first Friedmann equation — the trajectory of the universe itself. Input how much matter, energy, and radiation exist, plus when time began, and you can calculate how the cosmos is expanding, contracting, and when it all ends. Time had a start, she tells him. 13.8 billion years ago. Before that? Nobody knows. After the Big Bang, a few hundred million years of darkness before any star was born.
Jake, completely enchanted, asks the question that changes the temperature of the whole room: "What do you think time looks like?"
She tilts her head, trying to visualize something humans can only infer indirectly. She thinks of how people once struggled with a round Earth because the ground *felt* flat. She suspects time might be tangled with matter at the subatomic level, in ways we can't naturally detect. "I don't know. Yet."
"You gonna build a telescope? A time telescope?"
"Maybe I will."
Then, softer: "Well, if — *when* — you see time, will you show me?"
She nods. And the library announces it closes in five minutes.
Outside on Cross Campus, under that glowy, pointillistic sky, they stop on the lawn alone. Jake tries to look up through her eyes. He notices, for maybe the first time in his life, that not all stars are the same size — bigger dots interrupting dusty patches — and not all of them glow the same. Some are brighter; others more gently gorgeous. *Star* is one word, but there's breadth to the lights. "Do you want to study tomorrow?" he asks. "Yes, please," she says — and then, remembering her manners, bolts upright: "I'm Hopper." He's Berkeley. They point to their neighboring colleges and laugh, realizing they skipped the most basic question at Yale. *What college are you in?* They catch up on signs too — she's a Gemini, he's a Sagittarius. Then he walks her to Hopper's iron gate, under a streetlamp, the yellow windows, and 13.8 billion years of starlight. He leans in; in the same second she wraps her arms around his neck. They hold each other, frozen in the warmest way — all the passion that had been driving his focus in Bass now aimed entirely at her. "Night, Jake." "Sophie."
And walking home, he looks up at stars he wouldn't have noticed without her and thinks they have a sparkling crystal quality — like champagne bubbles frozen in time.
Now, dear listeners, comes the section I adored most. For the next few weeks, they study together every single night. And through those evenings, Jake learns that Sophie's genius IQ comes paired with interests so stunningly young it undoes him. "What was your favorite birthday?" she asks — and he can't remember the last time he celebrated his. "If you were an animal?" An eagle. "Favorite kind of doughnut?" She describes a pink one sprinkled with candy shards, and on study breaks he watches her devour cinnamon-sugared snickerdoodles, stroopwafels dunked in apple juice, and — yes — sugar straight from the packet.
When he turns the questions back on her, the answers land like stones in still water. Her favorite birthday? She's never had a birthday party. Her best friend? Her mom. Her biggest fear? Being in a crowd in a place she doesn't know. And the answer that matters most: *What do you believe that no one else does?* — "One day, we will see time."
Then, late that fall, four words change everything: "Do you want to come over?"
Sophie flips her problem set over, last page blank, and smiles yes. Her body wakes up — her heartbeat, her breath, the button snap on her belly. She's not used to living in her body; she once sat with a psychiatrist who asked, "Do you think you live in your head?" She hadn't understood the question then. Now she does. This is being out of her head. This is the thick of it, pure feeling.
They walk to Berkeley, holding hands loosely, and he explains his theory of himself: he doesn't think he has ADHD — he thinks he has the opposite. Superfocus. When he's locked onto one thing, everything else vanishes. "And I think you have it, too." And if he could have any superpower? "I'd help you know everything." Remember, he'd already bought her *Physics of the Impossible*, wrapped it himself, taped Skittles to the cover with a stick-on bow — "It's more so you have something from me in your room." The sexuality of that sentence shocked him the moment it left his mouth. Sophie just smiled, unembarrassed.
His room is radical minimalism: four blank walls, one pillow, a bare desk, a chair, a bureau. "Can I have a tour?" she teases, and he obediently gives one. "You ever study here?" "No, ma'am." *Ma'am?* He's never had a girl in this room. And then she says, "Maybe I should shut the door," and pulls it closed — "Sorry, I couldn't hear you. So loud." He laughs, relieved and undone, and walks toward her and kisses her. She blinks out his two windows of starry sky. Their minds fixate on the short seam connecting them. Outside, the hall is completely silent.
Then, the tenderness of the evening: she yawns and is instantly embarrassed. He offers her his smallest joggers and priciest PUMA shirt. She changes in the bathroom. They brush their teeth — she uses the spare brush still in its plastic package. He folds her shirt and jeans on his desk as carefully as he makes his bed. She turns off the light, and they slide into bed lit dark blue by starlight. His body curls into an S behind hers. He waits for her to speak; she only squeezes his arm. He kisses the back of her head and feels his first urge to say *I love you* — holds his tongue, and savors her until sleep.
At 6 a.m. his alarm hacks the morning apart. He silences it and resumes exactly where he was. She's sleeping in his arms, soft and small-boned, faint freckles spread across her nose like beige Milky Way dust. He kisses the nape of her neck. She turns around.
And then we cut — abruptly, brilliantly — to Professor Malchik's office, where Sophie is completely, obviously distracted. Because her mind is still back in that room, remembering the coziest she has ever been, skin to skin with the softest furnace, her back arched under the thinnest sheets.
Malchik has been feeding her his best material, too: a lesson on how emotions change time perception. Awe, flow, boredom, desire, grief, surprise. Surprise is special — the amygdala works overtime recording memories, and that denser reel of life makes time seem to slow down. He's listed a dozen articles in 8-point type because smaller fonts force concentration. He turns the page to the last one — "Fear and Time Perception" — and it's dead blank. She looked at that page the night Jake asked her over and thought she'd finish it later.
"Is this funny to you?" he asks.
"No, sir." She hasn't called him *sir* before — she touches her throat, sensing Jake.
Then she asks the question that stops the room: "What about love?"
He calls love a bit like desire. She refuses. "No, not desire. Real love." He offers awe instead — awe slows time, too, studies show; people who view epic mountains and glaciers remember more detail and estimate more time had passed. She shakes her head. Awe, she says, happens when you encounter something so big, beautiful, or complex that you're tempted to worship it. But real love is *between equals*. It's when you recognize someone you've never met, because somehow you knew they were the same. Awe is submission; love is connection. "It's different."
Then Sophie pushes further — and this, listeners, is the hinge of the entire book: "Do these emotions affect our *perception* of time, or time *itself*? What if being awestruck doesn't just *feel* slow — what if the world for you actually *does* slow down?"
Malchik thinks immediately of Einstein. Gravitational time dilation: the closer a clock is to gravity, the slower it ticks. Velocity time dilation: the faster an object moves, the slower its internal clock runs. An astronaut a year on the ISS ages nine milliseconds less than the rest of us. Both proven. But *emotional* time dilation? He makes a note. "That our emotions don't just reflect our world, but could change our world. That might be worth thinking about."
---
## Reader's Impressions & Star Rating
I have to be honest with you — this chapter hit me like a milkshake on an empty afternoon. What makes it soar isn't the romance alone; it's the way the love story and the physics are *the same story*. Sophie can't answer what time looks like, but she can describe real love with total precision. Jake can't remember his last birthday, but he can tell you exactly what focus feels like. These are two people who live inside their heads so completely that meeting each other is the first time either of them has been pulled into their bodies. "We disappear," he says in Bass — and then, pages later, Sophie realizes that being near him is precisely the opposite: she's not disappearing, she's *arriving*.
I loved the smallness of the details: the smell of nothing, the tap water next to the milkshake, the spare toothbrush still in plastic, the way he folds her jeans like he makes his bed. And I loved that the sexiest scene in the chapter is a man giving a "tour" of a desk. The writing never overexplains, never gushes — it lets silence do the work, which is so appropriate for a chapter about two people who bond over quiet.
And that final exchange with Malchik? Genius construction. The chapter sets up emotional time dilation as flirtation, then asks whether it might be *physics*. That's the promise of the title — *The Love Proof* — and Sophie has just unknowingly agreed to spend her life chasing it.
**⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Rating: 4.9 / 5 Stars**
## Next Chapter Prediction
Here's where I think we're heading. Sophie has just handed Professor Malchik a research question he cannot dismiss, and Jake has confessed — silently, in that dark blue room — something he didn't have the courage to say out loud. My prediction: the next chapter will begin the divergence. Sophie's obsession with "seeing time" will start to pull her away from the quiet rhythm of nightly study sessions, and Jake's "Future" doc — all those tabs about where the world is going — will begin to feel small next to a girl calculating when the universe ends. I expect the honeymoon hush of this chapter to crack into the first real conflict: he wants enough, she wants everything, and neither of them knows yet that those ambitions are about to collide. And I have a strong feeling Professor Malchik's notebook — that single line about emotional time dilation — is going to resurface years later, when it matters most.
To listen free the next reviews chatpers, please access website novelsaudio.com and search keyword: The Love Proof free digital audiobook or click the link in the description of this video or if you want to listen or read full the The Love Proof free digital audiobook please access website novelsaudio.com